Understanding Asphalt Shingles vs. Metal Roofs: Pros, Cons & Cost Comparisons

Nov 21, 2024

Deciding between asphalt shingles and metal roofing can be challenging, especially for homeowners in Florida and Georgia who need durable, weather-resistant roof materials. The right choice often depends on factors like budget, aesthetic preference, and climate resilience. The Tampa, Florida, and Atlanta, Georgia, areas experience diverse weather conditions, from intense heat and storms to periods of humidity, making the selection of roofing material crucial for homeowners hoping for long-term performance.

Why Asphalt Shingle & Metal Roofs Are Popular Choices

Asphalt shingle and metal roofing are two of the most widely chosen roof materials in Florida and Georgia, and for good reason.

Asphalt Shingles

These are known for their affordability and versatility, making them a go-to choice for many Tampa and Atlanta homeowners. Asphalt shingles can withstand intense winds and are available in assorted styles and colors to suit different home designs.

Metal Roofing

Metal roofs have gained popularity for their exceptional durability and energy efficiency. The reflective properties of metal help reduce heat absorption, which is beneficial in areas with intense sunlight like Tampa and Atlanta. Metal roofing is also resilient against heavy rain and fierce winds, making it suitable for the varying weather conditions in these regions.

Pros & Cons of Asphalt Shingle & Metal Roofing

Asphalt shingles are easier to work with and faster to install when compared to metal roofing. They also come in a wide range of colors and styles. However, their lifespan is generally about 15-30 years, which is shorter than metal, and they can be prone to damage from extreme heat and heavy storms. Asphalt shingle roofing may require more frequent repairs over time.

Metal roofing products offer an impressive lifespan, as they can last 40-70 years with minimal maintenance. In terms of energy efficiency, metal roofs reflect heat, reducing cooling costs during hot summers. They’re also resistant to fire, wind, and water damage.

The downsides of metal roofs are limited. They can be louder during heavy rain unless additional insulation is added, and they have aesthetic limitations—some homeowners may not prefer the modern, industrial look.

Cost Comparisons: Upfront Costs vs. Longevity

When comparing the costs of roof materials, asphalt shingles have the advantage of lower initial expenses, making them ideal for budget-conscious homeowners. However, their shorter lifespan means more frequent replacements, which can add up over time.

Metal roofing, while more expensive initially, offers longevity that may result in lower costs over the roof’s lifespan. The durability and minimal maintenance needs of metal roofs make them a wise long-term investment, especially for those planning to stay in their homes for many years.

Roofing Done Wright’s Roofing Solutions

Roofing Done Wright offers high-quality asphalt shingle and metal roofing options tailored to the needs of Florida and Georgia homeowners. Our asphalt shingle products provide reliable performance and come in a range of colors and styles. For those considering metal roofing, we offer options that combine resilience with aesthetic appeal, allowing homeowners to find a solution that matches their preferences and budget.

Make an Informed Choice

The choice between asphalt shingles and metal roofing is important, as it impacts your home’s value and protection. Roofing Done Wright is committed to helping Florida and Georgia homeowners select the right roof materials for their specific needs. Contact us today to learn more about our roof replacement services and schedule a consultation so we can provide personalized guidance.

A Proven Record of Exemplary Service

Read Rave Reviews From Our Satisfied Customers

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

“ Roofing Done Wright was great to work with. On time, professional and 100% satisfied with my roof and gutters. ”

Mike P.

“ Jonathan and his crew did an exceptional job! He far exceeded my expectations. Thank you, Jonathan!! ”

Marsha S

“ Roofing Done Wright did a fantastic job installing our roof from start to finish. I strongly recommend them! ”

Terry B.

“ Very responsive company and got the job done well and timely. Highly recommend. ”

K.N.C.

“ They did an excellent job. I would recommend them and I have done so. They are very professional, and they did an outstanding job. ”

Ken P.

“ I was very happy with the professionalism and thoroughness of my representative that worked with me from beginning to end. I was very happy with the services and consultation advice throughout the entire project. ”

Susan C.

“ Solid company that I refer my Real Estate clients to for all their roofing needs! Ward and Paul are AMAZING to work with. They are punctual and very accommodating. I have and will continue to recommend them. ”

April R.

“ As a Realtor, I rely on professionals like Paul McCalla to inspect roofs when listing homes and when I have a buyer. Paul has also worked on my personal Home roof. He is always on time ,explains the issues and honest. ”

Kay M.

“ I have gotten to know Matt Hopkins and Roofing Done Wright through my networking group. Matt is an outstanding guy who only operates with honesty and integrity. This roofing company is more concerned about customer service and taking care of people than they are the bottom dollar. They understand putting the customer first and they guarantee their work. Give them a call! ”

Jillian P.

“ This company is a well oiled machine! They are professional, efficient, reasonably priced and good communicators. I am on the HOA Board in a condo complex and they completed over 62 units for our community in a timely manner. I have already recommended them to two people. They are awesome! ”

Freedom M.

“ As a Property Management company, we interact with a great deal of contractors daily. One stands out above all the others. Ward Metcalfe and his team are amazing to work with. They always arrive when they say they will and get the job done on time. Good contractors are hard to find and I am glad we found them! Thank you! ”

Success Real Estate Brokers

“ Gatekeeper manages several hundred rental homes, and I own several dozen houses myself. Ward Metcalfe at Roofing Done Wright is our "go-to guy" for residential roofing. Quality is significantly better than the others we have tried. Customer service working with insurance companies is just great. He has saved us thousands. Ward Metcalfe is simply a good guy to boot! He really knows roofing. ”

Brett V.

“ Jonathan Holiday, the contact, was very responsive, professional, and delivered everything he said he would. His crew, Jacob, was excellent. Everyone was so personable, showed up, and they knew exactly what they were doing. Roofing Done Wright came highly recommended and they did not disappoint. ”

Randy H.

“ All of the requests that I asked to be done, Roofing Done Wright actually went above and beyond. ”

Ari K.

“ This company did a great job! I would definitely hire them again. Houston helped us pick out everything for our new roof and gutters. He was great. He knows a lot about the roofing business and was very helpful. Skyler was the onsite supervisor when our new roof was installed. He was also great and very knowledgeable. We are very happy with our new roof and gutters. ”

Rod C.